I had high hopes for Elijah Craig after having a couple of Manhattan’s at dinner one night and really enjoying them. What I found out from cracking open my own bottle is that it is better as a mixer than it is straight up. At under $30 bucks I guess I shouldn’t be too harsh on Elijah Craig, but I really did have high hopes for this bottle.
I’m going to give Elijah Craig a 57/100. I will finish the bottle, and I might buy another bottle, but only if I want to have a few bourbon cocktails (mixers).
- Sweet honey that fills your mouth and hangs on a few seconds after you swallow.
- Pleasant spice that blends well with the honey.
- Has the burn of a cheaper whiskey.
- Rough edges that don’t every really smooth out, they just get hidden under the honey and spice.
|Bib & Tucker||91||$75 / 750ml|
|Angels Envy||90||$65 / 750ml|
|Old Forester 1870||80||$55 / 750ml|
|Old Forester 1897||79||$55 / 750ml|
|Michters US 1 Small Batch||79||$45 / 750ml|
|Yellowstone||78||$35 / 750ml|
|Basil Hayden's||75||$35 / 750ml|
|Eagle Rare 10 Year Old Bourbon||75||$35 / 750ml|
|Hirsch Small Batch||74||$35 / 750ml|
|Proper Twelve||71||$30 / 750ml|
|Teeling Whiskey||70||$50 / 750ml|
|Cruzan No. 9 Spiced Rum||67||$20 / 750ml|
|Four Roses Small Batch||66||$30 / 750ml|
|Beer Barrel Bourbon||66||$35 / 750ml|
|Gentleman Jack||65||$35 / 750ml|
|Kraken Rum||64||$25 / 750ml|
|Elijah Craig||57||$27 / 750ml|
|Buffalo Trace||55||$25 / 750ml|
|Jack Daniels`||51||$25 / 750ml|
|Widow Jane||45||$70 / 750ml|
|Redemption||40||$30 / 750ml|
|Woodford Reserve||30||$13 / 50ml|
|Winchester Extra Smooth||15||$23 / 750ml|
|Jack Daniels Tennessee Honey||10||$20 / 750ml|
|Hill Billy||9||$20 / 750ml|
|Fireball||5||$18 / 750ml|